Welcome To Our ZHONGBO

Xiangjiang Industrial Park, Xiangjiang Street,

Honghuagang District, Zunyi City,Guizhou, China.

Call Us

+86-15599297368
Is Tungsten Carbide Toxic?
Home » News » Is Tungsten Carbide Toxic?

Is Tungsten Carbide Toxic?

Views: 222     Author: Hazel     Publish Time: 2025-02-02      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button
Is Tungsten Carbide Toxic?

Content Menu

What Is Tungsten Carbide?

Health Risks of Tungsten Carbide Exposure

>> 1. Pulmonary Toxicity

>> 2. Skin and Eye Irritation

>> 3. Systemic Effects

Occupational Safety Measures

Environmental Impact

>> Lifecycle Assessment and Mitigation

Toxicity in Specific Scenarios

>> 1. Military Applications

>> 2. Medical Implants

>> 3. Nanoparticle Exposure

Research and Studies

>> 1. Hard Metal Lung Disease Studies

>> 2. Cardiovascular Effects

>> 3. Cancer Risk

>> 4. Animal Studies

Regulatory and Safety Standards

>> 1. Occupational Exposure Limits

>> 2. NIOSH Recommendations

>> 3. Responsible Care and Sustainable Development

The Role of Cobalt

>> Alternative Binders

Recycling and Sustainability

>> Recycling Process

Conclusion

FAQs

>> 1. Is tungsten carbide jewelry safe to wear?

>> 2. Can tungsten carbide cause cancer?

>> 3. How do I handle tungsten carbide safely?

>> 4. What are the symptoms of tungsten poisoning?

>> 5. Is tungsten carbide environmentally friendly?

Citations:

Tungsten carbide (WC) is a widely used industrial material prized for its extreme hardness, wear resistance, and high melting point. It forms the backbone of cutting tools, drill bits, and even jewelry. However, its toxicity profile has sparked debates among scientists, manufacturers, and health organizations. This article examines the potential health and environmental risks of tungsten carbide, supported by research findings, safety guidelines, and real-world case studies.

 Tungsten Carbide Becoming Increasingly Popular

What Is Tungsten Carbide?

Tungsten carbide is a ceramic compound composed of tungsten (W) and carbon (C) atoms in a 1:1 ratio. It is typically sintered with a metallic binder, such as cobalt (5–15%) or nickel, to enhance toughness. This combination creates a "hard metal" used in high-stress applications like mining, aerospace, and medical devices.

Health Risks of Tungsten Carbide Exposure

1. Pulmonary Toxicity

Inhalation of tungsten carbide dust poses the most significant risk, particularly when combined with cobalt. Key findings include:

- Hard Metal Lung Disease (HMLD): A rare interstitial lung disease characterized by fibrosis and inflammation, linked to prolonged inhalation of WC-Co dust [4, 7].

- Lung Cancer: Epidemiological studies show an increased risk of lung cancer among workers exposed to WC-Co particles [1, 4].

- Acute Respiratory Effects: Short-term exposure may cause coughing, wheezing, and shortness of breath[3].

Mechanism: Cobalt in WC-Co alloys generates reactive oxygen species (ROS), damaging lung tissue and DNA[4]. Pure tungsten carbide exhibits minimal toxicity, but cobalt acts as a catalyst for oxidative stress.

2. Skin and Eye Irritation

Direct contact with WC dust or solutions may cause:

- Dermatitis: Allergic reactions, including rashes and itching, particularly in workers handling WC-Co tools [3, 18].

- Chemical Burns: Concentrated solutions or prolonged skin contact can lead to burns[18].

- Ocular Damage: Dust particles may irritate the eyes, leading to redness or corneal abrasions[3].

3. Systemic Effects

Emerging research highlights broader health impacts:

- Cardiovascular Disease: Elevated urinary tungsten correlates with hypertension and stroke risk[1].

- Bone Toxicity: Tungsten accumulates in bones, potentially increasing fracture risk [1, 4].

- Kidney Damage: Acute tungsten poisoning (rare) can cause tubular necrosis and renal failure [1, 5].

- Neurological Impairment: Hard-metal workers have shown evidence of mild-to-moderate neuropsychological impairment, particularly with regard to memory function[5].

Occupational Safety Measures

The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) recommends [3, 15]:

Control Measure Implementation
Ventilation Systems Use local exhaust hoods during grinding/polishing [3, 15].
Respiratory Protection N95 masks or powered air-purifying respirators3.
Protective Gear Gloves, goggles, and anti-static clothing3.
Workplace Hygiene Prohibit eating/drinking in contaminated areas3.
Medical Surveillance Regular lung function tests and chest X-rays3.

Environmental Impact

Tungsten carbide is chemically stable in its solid form, posing minimal environmental risk[6]. However:

- Soil/Water Contamination: Improper disposal of WC-Co waste may leach cobalt into ecosystems[2].

- Bioaccumulation: Aquatic organisms can absorb tungsten, though toxicity remains low compared to heavy metals[2].

- Ecosystem Disruption: The extraction of tungsten can lead to habitat disruption and biodiversity loss[2].

Regulatory bodies like the EPA now classify tungsten as an emerging contaminant, urging stricter disposal protocols[2].

Lifecycle Assessment and Mitigation

To fully understand the environmental implications, a lifecycle assessment of tungsten carbide seals is essential. This includes raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal[2].

1. Raw Material Extraction: Tungsten mining can lead to habitat destruction, soil erosion, and water pollution[2].

2. Manufacturing Process: The production of tungsten carbide is energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions [2, 11, 14].

3. Usage: Wear and tear during operation can lead to the release of degraded seal material, causing contamination[2].

4. Disposal: Improper disposal can release tungsten and other harmful substances into the environment[2].

Mitigation strategies include investing in research and development of alternative materials, promoting recycling and reusing, and implementing stricter regulations [2, 17].

some tungsten carbides

Toxicity in Specific Scenarios

1. Military Applications

Tungsten has been used as a replacement for lead in bullets. Studies suggest that under certain environmental conditions (low pH, low oxygen), tungsten can dissolve, potentially contaminating soil and water[5]. The long-term exposure risk of embedded shrapnel containing tungsten is a cause for concern[5].

2. Medical Implants

Tungsten is used in medical devices, such as tungsten-based shields during radiotherapy and coils for embolization[1]. These devices can degrade over time, leading to increased systemic exposure to tungsten[1]. Studies have detected elevated tungsten levels in the urine and blood of patients with these implants[1].

3. Nanoparticle Exposure

The effect of tungsten carbide nanoparticles on pulmonary toxicity is an area of growing concern[12]. Acute or chronic nanoparticle contact is a primary health risk, especially in occupational settings. Studies indicate that exposure to tungsten metal alloy, tungsten carbide-cobalt, or tungsten trioxide nanoparticles can lead to pulmonary inflammation, DNA damage, and oxidative stress[4].

Research and Studies

1. Hard Metal Lung Disease Studies

Research on hard metal lung disease has shown that chronic inhalation of tungsten carbide-cobalt particulates leads to interstitial lung disease, characterized by giant cell interstitial pneumonia and fibrosis [4, 7]. A study of former workers in a hard metal factory found that poorly regulated dust concentrations caused pulmonary abnormalities and severe illness[7].

2. Cardiovascular Effects

Studies have linked urinary tungsten concentrations to an increased risk of hypertension, peripheral arterial disease, and stroke[1]. Individuals with higher urinary tungsten concentrations have been found to have double the odds of reported stroke[5].

3. Cancer Risk

WC-Co mixtures are classified as probable human carcinogens due to the increased risk of lung cancer in occupational settings [1, 4]. Studies have also suggested a potential link between tungsten exposure and thyroid cancer and pediatric leukemia[1].

4. Animal Studies

Animal studies have shown that high doses of tungsten compounds can cause breathing problems and behavioral changes[16]. Research is ongoing to determine the relevance of these findings to humans[5].

Regulatory and Safety Standards

1. Occupational Exposure Limits

Various organizations have established occupational exposure limits for tungsten and tungsten carbide to protect workers [3, 15]. These limits are designed to minimize the risk of adverse health effects associated with inhalation of dust and fumes [3, 15].

2. NIOSH Recommendations

NIOSH recommends engineering controls, such as ventilation systems, and the use of personal protective equipment (PPE) to reduce worker exposure to tungsten carbide[3]. They also emphasize the importance of workplace hygiene and medical surveillance[3].

3. Responsible Care and Sustainable Development

Companies that manufacture tungsten carbide are encouraged to follow the principles of Responsible Care and Sustainable Development to minimize the environmental impact of their operations[15]. This includes implementing measures to reduce energy consumption, minimize waste generation, and prevent pollution [2, 15].

The Role of Cobalt

Cobalt is often used as a binder in tungsten carbide materials, and it plays a significant role in the toxicity of WC-Co mixtures. Cobalt can generate reactive oxygen species (ROS), leading to oxidative stress, DNA damage, and inflammation in lung tissue[4]. Some studies suggest that the majority of the toxicity associated with hard metal exposure is attributable to the effects of cobalt on respiratory tissues[5].

Alternative Binders

Research is ongoing to find alternative binder materials that are less toxic than cobalt[2]. These alternatives could help reduce the health risks associated with tungsten carbide exposure in occupational settings.

Recycling and Sustainability

Recycling tungsten carbide is an important way to reduce the environmental impact of its production and use [11, 17, 20]. Recycling requires much less energy than extracting and processing raw tungsten, which conserves resources and reduces the carbon footprint[20]. The International Tungsten Industry Association estimates that 30 to 35 percent of tungsten is recycled due to its high demand and the ability of the processing industry to treat most tungsten-based scrap metal[6].

Recycling Process

The recycling process involves collecting and processing tungsten carbide scrap metal to recover tungsten and other valuable materials[17]. This helps to close the loop and promote a circular economy[14].

Conclusion

Tungsten carbide itself is not highly toxic, but its combination with cobalt or nickel creates significant health hazards, particularly for occupational workers [1, 3, 4]. Chronic inhalation of WC-Co dust drives severe pulmonary and systemic diseases, while improper handling risks skin and eye damage [3, 4, 18]. Mitigation requires robust engineering controls, PPE, and ongoing medical monitoring [3, 15]. Environmentally, tungsten's stability limits ecological harm, though cobalt leaching warrants caution [2, 6]. Continued research, strict regulatory compliance, and sustainable practices are essential to minimizing the potential risks associated with tungsten carbide [2, 15].

tungsten carbide used for

FAQs

1. Is tungsten carbide jewelry safe to wear?

Pure tungsten carbide rings are inert and safe[6]. However, nickel-bound WC may trigger allergies in sensitive individuals[3].

2. Can tungsten carbide cause cancer?

WC-Co mixtures are classified as *probable human carcinogens* (IARC Group 2A) due to lung cancer risks in occupational settings [1, 4].

3. How do I handle tungsten carbide safely?

Use wet grinding methods, wear PPE, and ensure workspace ventilation [3, 15].

4. What are the symptoms of tungsten poisoning?

Acute cases involve nausea, seizures, and kidney failure[5]. Chronic exposure may cause respiratory or cardiovascular issues [1, 5].

5. Is tungsten carbide environmentally friendly?

Yes, due to its chemical inertness[6]. However, cobalt-containing WC requires careful disposal[2].

Citations:

[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11003356/

[2] https://www.lepuseal.com/a-news-the-environmental-impact-of-tungsten-carbide-seals-in-industrial-processes.html

[3] https://www.safetyandhealthmagazine.com/articles/work-safely-with-tungsten-carbide-2

[4] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8633919/

[5] https://patient.info/doctor/tungsten-poisoning

[6] https://tungstencarbide42.wordpress.com/environmental-impact-and-sustainability/

[7] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1472440/

[8] https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/19383/cdc_19383_DS1.pdf

[9] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0748233707076767?icid=int.sj-full-text.similar-articles.7

[10] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK598735/

[11] https://www.tungstenmetalsgroup.com/blog-blog/tungsten-scrap-metal-recycling

[12] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375584217_Effect_of_Tungsten_Carbide_Nanoparticles_on_Pulmonary_Toxicity_A_Systemic_Review

[13] https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article-abstract/172/9/1002/4283401?redirectedFrom=fulltext&login=false

[14] https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/16/12249

[15] https://hpvchemicals.oecd.org/ui/handler.axd?id=ed1c76bf-dad9-4baa-8d1b-70fed7f92862

[16] https://wwwn.cdc.gov/TSP/PHS/PHS.aspx?phsid=804&toxid=157

[17] https://www.itia.info/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/ITIA_Newsletter_2019_08.pdf

[18] https://nj.gov/health/eoh/rtkweb/documents/fs/1960.pdf

[19] https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp186.pdf

[20] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/carbide-recycling-more-sustainable-business-sandvik-coromant-6m58f

Table of Content list
  • Sign up for our newsletter
  • get ready for the future
    sign up for our newsletter to get updates straight to your inbox